We have a final statement from CP TAC:
We reviewed the internal VPN Advanced settings configuration and noticed that all gateways were set to use the last installed certificate for VPN connections.
Since the Cloud certificate renews itself automatically, it will always be selected, ensuring that remote access continues to work even if the VPN certificate has expired.
It's important to note that if you have already reinitialized the certificates, the VPN certificate will take priority.
Since you encountered an error during this process, it may have impacted the certificate installation, making the VPN certificate the latest installed one. This could potentially affect remote access connections.
Given this, we strongly recommend leaving the VPN certificate expired if your gateways are connected to SMP.
However, if you experience any VPN issues where the VPN certificate has expired and the SMP portal certificate is the last installed certificate, please let CP TAC know, and we will investigate further.
At this time, it appears that everything is functioning as expected.
CCSP - CCSE / CCTE / CTPS / CCME / CCSM Elite / SMB Specialist