topic Re: VSX cluster fundamental question in General Topics

VSX cluster fundamental question

Mark_Wheeler — Thu, 19 Mar 2020 14:34:23 GMT

Hi Folks

I am relatively new to VSX and i have a few question for my proper understanding. I only know clustering for ClusterXL or VRRP on gatways and form Management HA.

1. Can a VSX gateway (physical appliance) be clustered for HA (high availability)?

2. Can a VSX gateway (physical appliance) be clustered for LS (load sharing)?

3. Is it possible and does it even make sense to cluster virtual systems (virtual firewall on the vsx gateway) for HA on a VSX gateway or is this not necessary as both rely on the same hardware and would fail if the underlying hardware fails anyways?

4. Is it possible and does it even make sense to cluster virtual systems (virtual firewall on the vsx gateway) for LS on a VSX gateway or not?

5. Is it possible to cluster virtual systems over two or more VSX gateways (physical appliances)?

Can someone recommend a book or online course in order for me to learn VSX (and probably also MDS) in a structured way? You can also send me a PM in case recommendations are against the policy of this community.

I have booked a course few Weeks ago but it was canceled recently due to lack of attendants (not because of the Corona virus). Otherwise i would not bother you with my newbie questions 🙂

I am thankful for any helping answer,

Mark

Re: VSX cluster fundamental question

Wolfgang — Thu, 19 Mar 2020 15:11:26 GMT

Mark,

to your questions:

1. Can a VSX gateway (physical appliance) be clustered for HA (high availability)?

YES

2. Can a VSX gateway (physical appliance) be clustered for LS (load sharing)?

YES

You can't cluster a virtual system on one hardware, but your virtual system is high available if you run VSX-cluster

4. Is it possible and does it even make sense to cluster virtual systems (virtual firewall on the vsx gateway) for LS on a VSX gateway or not?

no, you can't run any cluster for a virtual system on one VSX gateway

5. Is it possible to cluster virtual systems over two or more VSX gateways (physical appliances)?

Yes, but you don't create a cluster of virtual systems, you must build a cluster with your VSX hardware.

Please have a look at the VSX documentation to better understanding of the VSX concept and VSX-cluster:

https://sc1.checkpoint.com/documents/R80.30/WebAdminGuides/EN/CP_R80.30_VSX_AdminGuide/html_frameset.htm

there is nice part for cluster.

To get high availability with VSX you have to use more then one hardware to built a VSX-cluster. This VSX-cluster can be run in HA or LS mode.

If in HA mode all virtual systems are active on one node and will be failover to the other in case of a problem.

LoadSharing mode gives you the chance to run virtual systems active on all of your VSX-cluster nodes. Meaning virtual system A running on node A and virtual system B running on node B. If node A is failing virtual system A will failover to node B and both virtual systems are active on node B.

Ther are some limitations with VSX-cluster in LS (you can't use virtual-router as an example). So you have to check for your requirements.

Wolfgang

Re: VSX cluster fundamental question

_Val_ — Thu, 19 Mar 2020 15:33:40 GMT

The the second question, the answer is, VSLS - Virtual System Load Sharing. Each VS pair will be in fact HA, but you can set up manual or automatic distribution of different VS being active on all cluster members.

VSLS also allows you effective use of more than two appliances. For the same VS, you have Active, Standby & Backup modes, if you have three or more physical VSX cluster members.

If this is not enough, and you want "real" load sharing, where the same Virtual System is active everywhere, use Maestro solution.