topic Re: Removing a Protocol from a Service Object? in API / CLI Discussion

Removing a Protocol from a Service Object?

Bob_Zimmerman — Sun, 29 Jan 2023 22:39:21 GMT

I see you can 'set services-tcp uid <UUID> protocol <protocol>' to add a protocol to a service, but is there a way to remove a protocol from a service? In SmartConsole, you set the protocol to -. I tried "None", "none", and a dash with no luck:

[Expert@DallasSA]# mgmt_cli -s session.txt -f json show service-tcp name testService { "uid" : "a10d3006-d85c-46de-b585-0112eb64ea5a", "name" : "testService", "type" : "service-tcp", "domain" : { "uid" : "41e821a0-3720-11e3-aa6e-0800200c9fde", "name" : "SMC User", "domain-type" : "domain" }, "port" : "12345", "protocol" : "DNS_TCP", "match-by-protocol-signature" : false, "override-default-settings" : false, "session-timeout" : 3600, "use-default-session-timeout" : true, "match-for-any" : false, "sync-connections-on-cluster" : true, "aggressive-aging" : { "enable" : true, "timeout" : 600, "use-default-timeout" : true, "default-timeout" : 0 }, "keep-connections-open-after-policy-installation" : false, "groups" : [ ], "comments" : "", "color" : "black", "icon" : "Services/TCPService", "tags" : [ ], "meta-info" : { "lock" : "locked by current session", "validation-state" : "ok", "last-modify-time" : { "posix" : 1675031424431, "iso-8601" : "2023-01-29T22:30+0000" }, "last-modifier" : "WEB_API", "creation-time" : { "posix" : 1675031424431, "iso-8601" : "2023-01-29T22:30+0000" }, "creator" : "WEB_API" }, "read-only" : false } [Expert@DallasSA]# mgmt_cli -s session.txt -f json set service-tcp uid a10d3006-d85c-46de-b585-0112eb64ea5a protocol "None" { "code" : "generic_err_invalid_parameter", "message" : "Invalid parameter for [protocol]. No such protocol : [ None ]" } [Expert@DallasSA]# mgmt_cli -s session.txt -f json set service-tcp uid a10d3006-d85c-46de-b585-0112eb64ea5a protocol "none" { "code" : "generic_err_invalid_parameter", "message" : "Invalid parameter for [protocol]. No such protocol : [ none ]" } [Expert@DallasSA]# mgmt_cli -s session.txt -f json set service-tcp uid a10d3006-d85c-46de-b585-0112eb64ea5a protocol "-" { "code" : "generic_err_invalid_parameter", "message" : "Invalid parameter for [protocol]. No such protocol : [ - ]" }

Re: Removing a Protocol from a Service Object?

PhoneBoy — Mon, 30 Jan 2023 01:48:46 GMT

Guessing that may not be something fully set table via the API.
@Omer_Kleinstern what say you?

Re: Removing a Protocol from a Service Object?

Bob_Zimmerman — Mon, 30 Jan 2023 15:43:58 GMT

Just checked 'show generic-object', and it shows the protoType property changing from 'null' to a UUID when I set it. I tried "null", both in quotes and out of quotes, and quotes around an empty string. None of these threw errors, but they also didn't change the object's protocol (as expected).

Re: Removing a Protocol from a Service Object?

PhoneBoy — Mon, 30 Jan 2023 20:06:01 GMT

Wonder if you can use set generic-object to actually change the setting?
In any case, seems like a bug that this doesn't work correctly.

Re: Removing a Protocol from a Service Object?

Omer_Kleinstern — Mon, 13 Feb 2023 11:22:37 GMT

Hi @Bob_Zimmerman ,

We will add the option to remove a protocol by providing "none" in in the next release and in future HFA of previous versions (PMTR-90609).

Thanks,

Omer

Re: Removing a Protocol from a Service Object?

Bob_Zimmerman — Mon, 13 Feb 2023 14:31:27 GMT

Thank you! I'll monitor and update this thread when the option appears.