topic Re: Gaia r80.10 tag vlan 1 and native vlan in Firewall and Security Management

Gaia r80.10 tag vlan 1 and native vlan

DPB_Point — Sun, 30 Jun 2019 19:41:41 GMT

Hello team,

I need to add a new subinterface for vlan 1, like:

bond2.1

Is there any way to tag vlan 1 in checkpoint? Cisco switches have the possibility to change native vlan for trunk and tag vlan 1 but I cannot find how to match this configuration in checkpoint.

Thank you in advance.

Daniel

Re: Gaia r80.10 tag vlan 1 and native vlan

Maarten_Sjouw — Sun, 30 Jun 2019 20:32:23 GMT

Nope this is not possible in GAIA.
The native VLAN is what it is and you cannot add a VLAN lower than 2.

Re: Gaia r80.10 tag vlan 1 and native vlan

Danny — Sun, 30 Jun 2019 20:41:54 GMT

Not supported in Gaia as described in sk110096.

Re: Gaia r80.10 tag vlan 1 and native vlan

DPB_Point — Mon, 01 Jul 2019 06:39:48 GMT

Thank you all guys.

Re: Gaia r80.10 tag vlan 1 and native vlan

DPB_Point — Mon, 01 Jul 2019 06:51:56 GMT

The SK does not seem to apply R80.10 version. Do you know how can I notify checkpoint to update it?

Thanks!

Re: Gaia r80.10 tag vlan 1 and native vlan

Ronen_Zel — Mon, 01 Jul 2019 07:01:37 GMT

At the bottom of each sk there is a "Give us Feedback" window. Enter your comments into that window and click "Submit". A Content Developer from the SK Team will be assigned to take care of your feedback.

Re: Gaia r80.10 tag vlan 1 and native vlan

Ronen_Zel — Mon, 01 Jul 2019 07:16:56 GMT

Please make sure you are logged in with your User Center credentials if you would like to hear back from us.

Re: Gaia r80.10 tag vlan 1 and native vlan

Ronen_Zel — Mon, 01 Jul 2019 07:20:17 GMT

One last comment: I am not sure why you thought sk110096 applies to R80.10. It clearly states the following versions:

R75.40, R75.40VS, R75.45, R75.47, R76, R76SP, R76SP.10, R76SP.10_VSLS, R76SP.20, R76SP.30, R77, R77.10, R77.20, R77.30.01

No R80.x here so actually nothing is wrong with the sk...

Re: Gaia r80.10 tag vlan 1 and native vlan

Maarten_Sjouw — Mon, 01 Jul 2019 07:32:49 GMT

@Ronen_Zel this is not supported in any version of GAIA so INCLUDING R80.x, that is why the SK should be adjusted.

Re: Gaia r80.10 tag vlan 1 and native vlan

Ronen_Zel — Mon, 01 Jul 2019 08:30:30 GMT

The "Versions" field is now updated to "All".

Re: Gaia r80.10 tag vlan 1 and native vlan

Mike_A — Mon, 01 Jul 2019 14:22:07 GMT

I had this issue about 2 years ago when I migrated all my gateways from 1Gb interfaces to 10Gb and started trunking on the 10G interfaces. For some reason a predecessor of mine thought it to be a good idea and use VLAN 1 as an ID for the main subnet.

I didn't realize that a bond0.1 could not be used until the night of cut over. What I did to work around this was, on the switch side, made the native VLAN on the interface to be 1, and allowed all the other VLAN's I wanted to tag. So the IP on my main bond0 would be the native IP on VLAN 1.

Re: Gaia r80.10 tag vlan 1 and native vlan

DPB_Point — Tue, 02 Jul 2019 10:07:54 GMT

Good workaround, I have configured L3 at bond interface too then change native vlan to be ID 1 at the switch side.

Thank you!

Re: Gaia r80.10 tag vlan 1 and native vlan

Mike_A — Tue, 02 Jul 2019 11:28:59 GMT

Glad it worked!

Re: Gaia r80.10 tag vlan 1 and native vlan

Wolfgang — Tue, 02 Jul 2019 14:05:57 GMT

Please had a look at the discussion here:

https://community.checkpoint.com/t5/General-Topics/Combine-VLAN-and-physical-interface-which-already-has-an/m-p/53611#M10712

and Creating VLAN interfaces on physical interface, which already has an assigned IP address in SecurePlatform OS / Gaia OS

It is not supported having an IP configured on the native interface if tagged VLANs used on that interface.

I know, it will work but you have problems if you need support from the vendor.

Wolfgang

Re: Gaia r80.10 tag vlan 1 and native vlan

Mike_A — Wed, 03 Jul 2019 14:39:56 GMT

I have a question here. If adding an IP address to the main interface that is utilizing VLAN tagging is not supported, and the support of VLAN ID 1 as a tagged VLAN is not supported. What is the suggestion on how to handle this? Burn another interface for a single VLAN when the use of VLAN ID 1 may be used in someones environment?

Understood that it is not best practice to use VLAN ID 1, but when it is already used in a network from predecessors that may not have done things, the best way, and changing the VLAN ID from 1 to something else may be a huge lift for some individuals and/or organizations (as this may pertain to access ports changing, vSwitch on ESX, etc.). What is the recommendation? I'm not refuting the fact that not using it is the right move, and or not adding an IP to a main interface that is using tags is not supported. My question is really about what the recommendation would be in this situation to possible help others in the future before they get into this situation.

Re: Gaia r80.10 tag vlan 1 and native vlan

Danny — Wed, 03 Jul 2019 15:47:12 GMT

Correct. Use a separate interface and attach it natively to your switch. Then have your switch route it into Vlan 1.

Re: Gaia r80.10 tag vlan 1 and native vlan

Julian_Sanchez — Fri, 14 Aug 2020 22:11:43 GMT

Hi Mike,

Two weeks ago we had this problem. We was migrating to 10GB interface. We want to migrate the gateway of network VLAN 1 to the firewall, however we cant. What was your solution? Because we had the vlan native in the switch VLAN ID 1.

Because another options is use other interface only for vlan 1 in mode access, however we lose the capacity of interface 10GB. Or your recomendation is migrate or change VLAN 1I know is the best practices but now is a little complex in our infraestructure.

Re: Gaia r80.10 tag vlan 1 and native vlan

Mike_A — Sat, 15 Aug 2020 14:09:37 GMT

Julian,

Just to be clear, what I had proposed in this thread is not supported by Check Point as @Wolfgang had posted above. I think we all agree it will work, but if you have issues, TAC may not support you.

With that said, as long as you have the native VLAN ID you require configured on the trunk port you would set an IP for VLAN 1 on the physical NIC. Below is an example.

Gateway Physical Interface = eth1-01

VLAN 1 = 10.0.1.0/24

VLAN 2 = 10.0.2.0/24

VLAN 3 = 10.0.3.0/24

clish commands

set interface eth1-01 state on

add interface eth1-01 vlan 2

add interface eth1-01 vlan 3

set interface eth1-01 ipv4-address 10.0.1.1 mask-length 24

set interface eth1-01.2 ipv4-address 10.0.2.1 mask-length 24

set interface eth1-01.3 ipv4-address 10.0.3.1 mask-length 24

The line highlighted in RED is what is not supported when you are using a trunk on eth1-01.

Hope this helps/explains.

- Mike

Re: Gaia r80.10 tag vlan 1 and native vlan

Sanjay_S — Tue, 05 Apr 2022 06:53:08 GMT

Hi All,

We are facing issues with VLAN 1 in CP1550 embedded device. So even this device doesn't support the VLAN1 as it treat as native vlan 1 by default?

Regards,

Sanjay S

Re: Gaia r80.10 tag vlan 1 and native vlan

CheckPointerXL — Tue, 15 Oct 2024 15:23:24 GMT

this limitation is valid also for Bond interfaces i guess... right?